Currently, there are three types of antibiotics widely used to treat BV. I'm going to cover some basic information about each.
This is an overview of Clindamycin, which comes in three forms.
Clindamycin (oral)
- Description: oral capsules, typical regimen is 300 mg, 2x a day, for 7 days
- Cure Rate: 94%
- Pros: a broad-spectrum antibiotic, provides an alternative to patients who can't take Flagyl; does not cause nausea when consumed with alcohol
- Cons:
- may cause overgrowth of Streptococcus (Strep) bacteria
- From the literature that patients receive with this drug - "WARNING: This medicine should be used only for serious infections because infrequently there are severe, rarely fatal, intestinal problems (pseudomembranous colitis) that can occur."
Cleocin (vaginal cream)
- Description: 3- or 7-day vaginal ovules/suppositories
Clindesse (vaginal cream)
- Description: one-dose vaginal cream
- Cure Rate: The company claimed 88% (PDF file), but was cited by the FDA (PDF file) for overstating that figure, among other claims: "The e-Pharm/alert e-mail is false or misleading because it overstates and misrepresents the efficacy of Clindesse, presents unsubstantiated superiority and patient compliance claims, and minimizes the risks and limitations to the indication associated with Clindesse."
- Pros: a broad-spectrum antibiotic, provides an alternative to patients who can't take Flagyl; does not cause nausea when consumed with alcohol; one-dose convenience
- Cons:
- Clindesse can be systemically absorbed, and can cause all the side effects of oral Clindamycin, such as pseudomembranous colitis
- From this source: "... clindamycin vaginal cream, which was frequently used for bacterial vaginosis during pregnancy, is no longer approved because it results in a strep vaginosis."
My Recommendation:
Should you use Clindamycin or Clindesse for BV? In short, no. Doctors used to prescribe it often, and may still do. But I keep finding more sources that say that it causes Strep bacteria overgrowth, and that is a real concern. Not to mention that Clindesse is apparently not very effective, and the company that makes it has overstated how well it works. So these are definitely more reasons to avoid it. Many women have used Clindamycin and Clindesse (myself included) in the past. But I think we need to stay away from it from now on.
Unless you have a very compelling reason to avoid Flagyl (e.g., an allergy), I would recommend that you avoid all forms of Clindamycin. (And wanting to not go without drinking alcohol for a week is not a compelling reason!)
4 comments:
I have used flagyl for years for my BV, but it always seems to come back. Im at the end of the rope now and I will try anything. Today is day one of my oral clindamycin, I hope it works... 3yrbvldy
Thanks for writing, 3yrbvldy. Sounds like you've been through what I call the "vicious cycle."
Please read my posts titled, "BV: The Vicious Cycle," and "OTC Treatment #1: Fem-Dophilus (Thumbs Up)."
Good luck!
Hi I've been going through the "Vicious cycle" for almost three years now and it seems that no one can help me. I took flagyl and/r clindesse about 4 times last year. I decided to take clindesse again last night (before reading this post) and now I am really scared. I have a headache, my toes and hands are numb and I am extremely constipated (sorry so graphic). My plan was to take the clindesse and pump myself with good bacteria (which I am just now learning about) and also laying off sex for a month or two (at least unprotected sex). I only get it when i have unprotected sex with my husband. Do you have any other suggestions to help break the cycle?
Hi yanni. If you are experiencing numbness, you need to call your doctor.
As far as the constipation goes, it *may* be because the clindesse has messed with your intestinal flora (always a risk with all antibiotics, but especially clindamycin) - so you might want to try probiotics. Have you tried Activia or Yo-Plus yogurt? There is also Culturelle. If the constipation doesn't improve, definitely contact your doctor.
Post a Comment